The Criminal Justice S4 ending has left viewers stunned. Pankaj Tripathi once again delivers an emotionally nuanced performance as advocate Madhav Mishra, guiding us through a dark, twisted courtroom drama. The central mystery? Who killed Roshni Saluja? Here’s a detailed breakdown of the ending — spoiler alert!
👩⚖️ Who Was Roshni Saluja?
Roshni Saluja, portrayed with admirable depth, was the wife of prominent businessman Siddharth Saluja. What began as a seemingly loving marriage turned into a nightmare when Siddharth found Roshni dead in their upscale Mumbai apartment. Circumstantial evidence and Siddharth’s distressed behaviour make him the prime suspect — but was he truly guilty?
🕵️♂️ The Case: From Beloved Wife to Victim
Early episodes drive a wedge between the couple. Siddharth’s frantic narration, fight with Roshni, and his secret phone call immediately raise suspicion. As the police dig deeper, they uncover Roshni’s troubled past, including estrangement from her family and a hidden affair. Each new detail complicates the picture, making Siddharth seem both caring and suspicious.
🎭 Madhav Mishra: The Moral Compass
Enter Pankaj Tripathi’s Madhav Mishra, a seasoned lawyer who firmly believes in justice, not just winning. Unlike contemporary lawyers using flashy tactics, Mishra takes the time to dissect not just the facts, but the emotional truth behind them. He discovers inconsistencies in evidence, biases in witnesses, and — surprisingly — sympathy for Siddharth’s grief-stricken state.
🧩 Key Clues Leading to the Culprit
- Roshni’s Affair: Mishra learns that Roshni secretly dated her colleague, meeting him in the same apartment on the day of her death.
- The Blood-Stained Blouse: Found hidden in Roshni’s closet, it wasn’t Siddharth’s blood but that of her lover, verified through lab tests.
- Apartment Key Card Timestamps: Security footage and key records reveal someone else entered the apartment after Siddharth left, suggesting third-party involvement.
🔓 The Courtroom Confrontation
As tension rises in court, Mishra exposes the lover’s lies. He presents audio clips, timestamped entries, and the hidden blouse as evidence. The courtroom — previously convinced of Siddharth’s guilt — begins to shift its perspective. The mood becomes electric when Mishra dramatically reveals the real murderer: Roshni’s lover, acting out of jealousy and fear after Roshni threatened to leave him.
⚖️ The Verdict: Justice Unfolds
The judge convicts Roshni’s lover, handing him a lengthy prison sentence for premeditated murder. Siddharth is cleared of charges, his grief and love finally validated. Even the judge acknowledges Madhav Mishra’s unwavering commitment to the truth, emphasising that justice aims to uncover real facts, not just win points.
💔 Why the Ending Matters
- For Siddharth: It’s a bittersweet relief. His reputation is saved, but the truth about Roshni’s secret life and tragic death continues to haunt him.
- For Mishra: The case reaffirms his moral compass — justice must rise above media frenzy, societal bias, and circumstantial evidence.
- For Viewers: The show reminds us how easy it is to rush to judgment. It urges us to look beyond the surface and consider emotional complexity in legal battles.
🎥 Looking Ahead: What Season 5 Could Explore
- Mishra’s Inner World: Will we explore his family, personal trauma, or past cases?
- More Grey Morality: The next season might feature a case where the defendant is guilty, but the reasoning is nuanced and sympathetic.
- Systemic Flaws: Expect deeper commentary on media influence, police handling, and courtroom ethics.
✅ Final Thoughts
The explosive twist in Criminal Justice Season 4 — revealing Roshni Saluja’s lover as her killer — is more than just a dramatic reveal. It’s a conversation starter about grief, hidden truths, and how easily public opinion can condemn the innocent. With Pankaj Tripathi’s Madhav Mishra at the helm, the show continues to shine a light on the emotional and ethical complexities of justice in India.
If you’ve watched the finale, I’d love to hear your take. Did you suspect the affair all along? Are you glad Siddharth got exonerated? Let’s dive into the comments below!
